Teams
| Where They Came From | |||
| High School | Location | High School | Location |
| Archbishop Molloy High School | Briarwood, NY | LaSalle Academy | New York, NY |
| Automotive High School | Brooklyn, NY | Lehman High School | Bronx, NY |
| Bartlett High School | Anchorage, AK | Livingston Manor High School | Livingston Manor, NY |
| Bayside High School | Palm Beach, FL | Long Island City High School | Long Island City, NY |
| Belfast High School | Belfast, Germany | Martin Luther King High School | New York, NY |
| Bishop Loughlin Memorial High School | Brooklyn, NY | McKee High School | Staten Island, NY |
| Cardinal Hayes High School | Bronx, NY | Miami Carol City High School | Miami, FL |
| Cardinal Spellman High School | Bronx, NY | Middletown High School | Middletown, NY |
| Chapel Field Christian High School | Pine Bush, NY | Minisink Valley High School | Slate Hill, NY |
| Chester Academy High School | Chester, NY | Monroe Woodbury High School | Central Valley, NY |
| Christ the King High School | Middle Village, NY | Monsignor Farrell High School | Staten Island, NY |
| Cornwall High School | New Windsor, NY | Monticello High School | Monticello, NY |
| Delaware Valley High School | Milford, PA | Mount Vernon High School | Mt Vernon, NY |
| East Anchourage High School | Anchourage, AK | Newburgh Free Academy | Newburgh, NY |
| East Brunswick High School | East Brunswick, NJ | New Utrucht High School | Brooklyn, NY |
| Eldred High School | Eldred, NY | Ossining High School | Ossining, NY |
| Ellenville High School | Ellenville, NY | Pine Bush High School | Pine Bush, NY |
| Elmont High School | Elmont, NY | Port Jervis High School | Port Jervis, NY |
| Erasmus High School | Brooklyn, NY | Shabaaz High School | Newark, NJ |
| Far Rockaway High School | Far Rockaway, NY | Sheepshead Bay High School | Brooklyn, NY |
| Florida High School | Florida, NY | South Shore High School | Brooklyn, NY |
| Fox Lane High School | Bedford, NY | St. Pius High School | Albuquerque, NM |
| Goshen High School | Goshen, NY | Thomas Edison High School | Jamaica, NY |
| Harmony Christian High School | Middletown, NY | Uniondale Senior High School | Uniondale, NY |
| James I. O’Neal High School | Highland Falls, NY | Valley Central High School | Montgomery, NY |
| John Adams High School | Ozone Park, NY | Wallkill Senior High School | Wallkill, NY |
| John S. Burke Catholic High School | Goshen, NY | Warwick High School | Warwick, NY |
| Kingston High School | Kingston, NY | Washingtonville High School | Washingtonville, NY |
| Largo High School | Largo, FL | Westinghouse High School | Brooklyn, NY |
1981-1982 Colts
| Kevin Hannon | John S. Burke H.S. |
| Vance Levin | Monticello H.S. |
| Bob Sailor | Monroe Woodbury H.S. |
| Ricky Scheibner | Minisink Valley H.S. |
| Kevin Wilcox | Livingston Manor H.S. |
| Daniel Brundage | Warwick Valley H.S. |
| Todd Hill | Erasmus H.S. |
| James Peterson | Newburgh Free Academy |
| Nick Santoro | – |
| John Tiso | Newburgh Free Academy |
1982-1983 Colts
| Mike Petermann | Pine Bush H.S. |
| Keith Russel | Goshen H.S. |
| Brian Yearwood | Minisink Valley H.S. |
| John Williams | Middletown H.S. |
| James Peterson | Newburgh Free Academy |
| Sid Monroe | Newburgh Free Academy |
| Corry Weaver | Lehman H.S. |
| Chris Rohrberg | Warwick H.S. |
| John Tiso | Newburg Free Academy |
| Bob Mosloski | Newburgh Free Academy |
| Kevin Crill | James I. O’Neal H.S. |
| Marty Gaspard | Christ the King H.S. |
| Tyrus Fleetwoord | – |
| Joe Truglia | – |
| Tom Pulverent | – |
| Tom Didato | – |
1983-1984 Colts
| Tony Dickens | Albany H.S. |
| Sid Monroe | Newburgh Free Academy |
| Jim Berg | Goshen H.S. |
| Ken McCalla | Middletown H.S. |
| Keith Russel | Goshen H.S. |
| Dennis Davis | Minisink Valley H.S. |
| Bob Masloski | Newburgh Free Academy |
| Steve Holmbraker | Belfast H.S. |
| Tom Chuckran | Port Jervis H.S. |
| Jim Foreman | Bishop Loughlin H.S. |
| Andrei Giglevitch | Washingtonville H.S. |
| Randy Seligman | Goshen H.S. |
| Jose Olivencia | – |
1984-1985 Colts
| Ernesto Wilson | Bishop Loughlin H.S. |
| Joe Privot | Long Island City |
| Rick Brewer | Middletown H.S. |
| Stan Buzcak | Port Jervis H.S. |
| Tom Watson | Monticello H.S. |
| Joe Angelastro | Middletown H.S. |
| Dennis Davis | Minisink Valley H.S. |
| Kevin Andryshak | Goshen H.S. |
| Mike Petermann | Pine Bush H.S. |
| Bob Boylan | Pine Bush H.S. |
| Paul Newman | Pine Bush H.S. |
| Roger Stack | John S. Burke H.S. |
1985-1986 Colts
| Kevin Andryshak | Goshen H.S. |
| Matt Dillon | Minisink Valley H.S. |
| Roger Stack | John S. Burke H.S. |
| Stan Buczak | Port Jervis H.S. |
| Joe Smith | Deleware Valley H.S. |
| Dave Brisbon | Martin Luther King H.S. |
| Craig Smith | Deleware Valley H.S. |
| Bob Boylan | Pine Bush H.S. |
| Todd Hill | Erasmus H.S. |
| Sean Bridgeford | Cornwall H.S. |
| Kevin Butler | John S. Burke H.S. |
| Tom Watson | Monticello H.S. |
| Jason McAllister | Newburgh Free Academy |
1986-1987
| Neil Jenkins | Uniondale H.S. |
| Matt Dillon | Minisink Valley H.S. |
| Ed Wiley | Mount Vernon H.S. |
| Jason McAllister | Newburgh Free Academy |
| Joe Smith | Deleware Valley H.S. |
| Craig Smith | Deleware Valley H.S. |
| Dave Brisbon | Martin Luther King H.S. |
| John Kennedy | Chester Academy |
| John Steinberg | Cornwall H.S |
1987-1988
| Ed Wiley | Mount Vernon H.S. |
| Jason McAllister | Newburgh Free Academy |
| Kevin Butler | John S. Burke H.S. |
| John Kennedy | Chester Academy |
| John Steinberg | Cornwall H.S |
| Cory White | Middletown, H.S. |
| Ed Perry | Monticello H.S. |
| Mike Brown | Cornwall H.S |
| Dave Killin | Pine Bush H.S. |
1988-1989
| Garfield Syblis | G.E.D. |
| Damian Brown | Middletown H.S. |
| Mike Carroll | John S. Burke H.S. |
| John Kennedy | Chester H.S. |
| Jaime Williams | Middletown H.S. |
| Paul Bertram | Eldred H.S. |
| John Skivington | Monroe Woodbury H.S. |
| Martin Hossan | Minisink Valley H.S. |
| George Coates | Pine Bush H.S. |
| George Brown | Cornwall H.S |
| Matt Carey | Monroe Woodbury H.S. |
| Darrell Burnes | Newburgh Free Academy |
| Sean Bailey | Neburgh Free Academy |
| Danny Williams |
1989-1990
| Garfield Syblis | G.E.D. |
| Sean Bailey | Neburgh Free Academy |
| Anthony Evans | Bishop Loughlin H.S. |
| Jason Clemmons | Minisink Valley H.S. |
| Jerry Levin | Monticello H.S. |
| Jermaine Syville | Westinghouse H.S. |
| James Woolery | South Shore H.S. |
| George Coates | Pine Bush H.S. |
| Al Alfonso | Monroe Woodbury H.S. |
| John Skivington | Washingtonville H.S. |
| Paul Bertram | Eldred H.S. |
1990-1991
| Anthony Evans | Bishop Loughlin H.S. |
| Tom Rickard | Minisink Valley H.S. |
| Tim Reynolds | Middletown H.S. |
| Curlie Dillard | Newburgh Free Academy |
| Jerry Levin | Monticello H.S. |
| Al Alfonzo | Monroe Woodbury H.S. |
| Kevin Douthit | John S. Burke H.S. |
| Desmond Washington | Middletown H.S. |
| Ed Navarro | Ossining H.S. |
| Hans Boller | Kingston H.S. |
| Rick Rivera | Port Jervis H.S. |
| Rich Kennedy | Chester Academy |
| Dave O’Conner | Middletown H.S. |
| Bob Sailor | Monroe Woodbury H.S. |
| Binor Faison | Newburgh Free Academy |
1991-1992
| Tom Rickard | Minisink Valley H.S. |
| James Wollery | South Shore H.S. |
| Kurtis Curry | Far Rockaway H.S. |
| Desmond Washington | Middletown H.S. |
| Bill Mullady | Washingtonville H.S. |
| Kevin Douthit | John S. Burke H.S. |
| Binor Faison | Newburgh Free Academy |
| Andy Walsh | John S. Burke H.S. |
| Dave Writer | Minisink Valley H.S. |
| Rob Carroll | John S. Burke H.S. |
| Jermaine Syville | Westinghouse H.S. |
| Bob Decker | Pine Bush H.S. |
1992-1993
| Bob Decker | Pine Bush H.S. |
| Al Estrada | Middletown H.S. |
| Jim Kelly | Middletown H.S. |
| Paul Marvulli | Valley Central H.S. |
| Bill Mullady | Washingtonville H.S. |
| T.J. Nelson | Monroe Woodbury H.S. |
| Andy Walsh | John S. Burke H.S. |
| Jermaine Turner | |
| Harry Williams | |
| Peter Thompson | |
| Rob Kuhn | |
| Doc Lamptry |
1993-1994
| Larry Monroe | Middletown H.S. |
| Rob Carroll | John S. Burke H.S. |
| Glen Frink | Elenville H.S. |
| T.J. Nelson | Monroe Woodbury H.S. |
| Pete Mullady | Washingtonville H.S. |
| Lloyd Freckelton | Minisink Valley H.S. |
| Tom Matirano | Washingtonville H.S. |
| Jose Santiago | Middletown H.S. |
| Chris Carter | Middletown H.S. |
| Damian Paylo | |
| Dan Tambellini | |
| Ron Cover | |
| Harry Williams |
1994-1995
| Jose Santiago | Middletown H.S. |
| T.J. Mariconi | Monroe Woodbury H.S. |
| Oneil Gooden | Elmont H.S. |
| George Sanchez | John S. Burke H.S. |
| Pete Mullady | Washingtonville H.S. |
| Jason Tucker | Middletown H.S. |
| Rob McCaffrey | Florida H.S. |
| Jason Kahmar | Port Jervis H.S. |
| Charles Mann | Middletown H.S. |
1995-1996
| Khary Hoyle | LaSalle Academy |
| John Olsen | Mons. Farrell H.S. |
| Jamaal Ennis | Thomas Edison H.S. |
| Justin Haffner | LaSalle Academy |
| Joe Wiggins | Middletown H.S. |
| Lou VanLeeuween | John S. Burke H.S. |
| tom Koziak | James I. O’Neil H.S. |
| Edmund Leahy | McKee H.S. |
| Matt Vitek | St. Pius(Los Lunas, NM) |
| Phil Bertholf | Middletown H.S. |
| Jeremy Eagan | Port Jervis H.S. |
| Keith Kiszka | Minisink Valley H.S. |
| Tramaine Johnson |
1996-1997
| Jamaal Ennis | Thomas Edison H.S. |
| Khary Hoyle | LaSalle Academy |
| Justin Haffner | LaSalle Academy |
| Naz Henry | Middletown H.S. |
| Matt Vitek | St.Pius(Los Lunas, NM) |
| Brian Finnegan | Warwick H.S |
| Scott Cromie | Port Jervis H.S. |
| Jerry Shine | Goshen H.S. |
| Shane Burke | Goshen H.S. |
| Cory Jackson | Newburgh Free Academy |
| Troy Davis | Valley Central H.S. |
| Mike Bradley | Middletown H.S. |
| Eric Gruner | Harmony Christian H.S |
| Josh Bailey | Harmony Christian H.S |
| Brian Perico | Middletown H.S. |
| Tom Napier | Minisink Valley H.S |
1997-1998
| Donte Devoe | East Anchourage H.S. |
| Jerry Shine | Goshen H.S. |
| John Olsen | Mnsr Farrell H.S. |
| Joe Wiggins | Middletown H.S. |
| Brian Finnegan | Warwick H.S. |
| Fred Williams | Pine Bush H.S. |
| Josh Bailey | Harmony Christian H.S |
| Mike McDonald | Goshen H.S. |
| Art Alzamora | Valley Central H.S. |
| Brian McDevitt | Middletown H.S. |
| Clarence Walker | Bartlett H.S. |
| John Lane | East Anchourage H.S. |
| Steve Distefano | Minisink Valley H.S. |
| Eric Gruner | Harmony Christian H.S |
1998-1999
| James Lighty | New Utricht H.S. |
| John Lane | East Anchourage H.S. |
| Gordon James | Automotive H.S. |
| Tyrelle Scott | Miami Carol City H.S. |
| Naz Henry | Middletown H.S. |
| Art Alzamora | Valley Central H.S. |
| Rahman Alexander | Middletown H.S. |
| Justin Holliday | GED |
| Tim McGuire | Chester Academy |
| Luke McDonald | Warwick H.S. |
| Dan Yanosh | Pine Bush H.S. |
| Chris LaForte | John S. Burke H.S. |
| Joe Sanchez |
1999-2000
| Anthony Hardy | Newburgh Free Academy |
| Adrian Allman | Sheepshead Bay H.S. |
| Tim McGuire | Chester Academy |
| Dan Yanosh | Pine Bush H.S. |
| Auggie Sanchez | Newburgh H.S. |
| Kenny Gladden | Cardinal Hayes H.S. |
| Dan Gonzalez | Deleware Valley H.S. |
| Walter Rickard | John S. Burke H.S. |
| Allen Stohl | Washingtonville H.S. |
| Gordon James | Automotive H.S. |
2000-2001
| Anthony Hardy | Newburgh Free Academy |
| Walter Rickard | John S. Burke H.S. |
| Dan Gonzalez | Deleware Valley H.S. |
| Efrain Barral | Wallkill H.S. |
| Lydon Noriega | John Adams H.S. |
| Pay Schultz | John S. Burke H.S. |
| Dan Rickard | John S. Burke H.S. |
| Auggie Sanchez | Newburgh Free Academy |
| Anthony Pena | John S. Burke H.S. |
| Jesse Rose | John S. Burke H.S. |
| Jeremie Bennett | Newburgh Free Academy |
2001-2002
| Dan Rickard | John S. Burke H.S. |
| Dan Gonzalez | Deleware Valley H.S. |
| Anthony Sampson | Bayside H.S. |
| Pat Schultz | John S. Burke H.S. |
| Nafiys Blakewood | Shabazz H.S. |
| Jesse Rose | John S. Burke H.S. |
| Phil Stewart | Monticello H.S. |
| J.D. Fogarty | Newburgh Free Academy |
| Anthony Castro | Washingtonville H.S. |
| Gauren Blair | Middletown H.S. |
| Tyrelle Jones | |
| Kevin Byrne | |
| Bill Hogan |
2002-2003
| Anthony Sampson | Bayside H.S. |
| J.D. Fogarty | Newburgh Free Academy |
| Aramis Ramos | Washingtonville H.S. |
| Chris Vellenga | Minisink Valley H.S. |
| Ian Cooper | Newburgh Free Academy |
| Trevor Wiggins | Newburgh H.S. |
| Randy Vellenga | Minisink H.S. |
| Mike Lavan | Goshen H.S. |
| Corey Dixon | Valley Central H.S. |
| Troy Smalls | Newburgh Free Academy |
| Ron Dross |
2003-2004
| Devon Sullivan | Cornwall H.S. |
| Devin Diggs | Christ the King H.S. |
| Luke Mortenson | Minisink Valley H.S. |
| randy Vellenga | Minisink Valley H.S. |
| Neal Wilkins | Middletown H.S. |
| Tim Clifford | Chester Academy |
| Tim Charles | Pine Bush H.S |
| tim Rickard | John S. Burke H.S. |
| Trevor Wiggins | Newburgh Free Academy |
| Jonathan Thorpe | Newburgh Free Academy |
2004-2005
| Dan Lang | Minisink Valley H.S. |
| Justin Chiarot | Chapel Field H.S. |
| Luke Mortenson | Minisink Valley H.S. |
| Brian Clifford | Chester Academy |
| Devin Diggs | Christ the King H.S. |
| Mike Clavell | Chester Academy |
| Tim Rickard | John S. Burke H.S. |
| Dave Canazone | Minisink Valley H.S. |
| Taurus Johnson | Newburgh Free Academy |
| Tom Hayes | Middletown H.S. |
| Tim Clifford | Chester Academy |
| John Alexander | Fox Lane H.S. |
| Tim Charles | Pine Bush H.S. |
| Alex Martinez | Newburgh Free Academy |
2005-2006
| Dan Lang | Minisink Valley H.S. |
| Cory Bertholf | Middletown H.S. |
| Brian Harnischfeger | Archbishop Molloy H.S. |
| Stefan Bonneau | Middletown H.S. |
| Ben Bowman | Cardinal Spellman H.S. |
| Taurus Johnson | Newburgh H.S. |
| Danny Perez | Washingtonville H.S. |
| Adrian Carvalho | Fox Lane H.S. |
| Kola Drejaj | Minisink Valley H.S. |
| Alex Martinez | Newburgh H.S. |
| Steve Edwards | Kingston H.S. |
| Gordon Hurley | East Brunswick H.S. |